gilahank@mcbrides_resources:~# session --user=student_
[ HOME ] [ CONNECTION: SECURE ]
gilahank@mcbrides_resources:~/apple-google-privacy# cat readme.txt

Apple & Google Privacy

A timeline of privacy lawsuits, settlements, and violations involving Apple and Google.

On This Page

Apple Privacy

A chronological list of major privacy-related lawsuits involving Apple, particularly focused on iOS and user data practices (oldest first):

$ cat ./apple-privacy-lawsuits.tsv — oldest first
Year(s)CaseAllegationDetailsOutcome / Status
2019–2025Siri Privacy Lawsuit (Lopez v. Apple Inc.)Apple’s Siri-enabled devices recorded private conversations without user consent — even without the “Hey Siri” trigger.Recordings included sensitive medical, business, and personal discussions. These were allegedly sent to Apple servers and reviewed by contractors.Apple agreed to a $95 million settlement in 2025. Eligible users could claim up to $20 per device.
2021–2025Siri Voice Assistant Class Action (EU & US)Siri recorded conversations due to accidental activations and shared data with third-party contractors.Apple proposed a settlement including deletion of unlawfully collected data and symbolic compensation.Regulatory Commentary: The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) criticized Apple’s practices under GDPR.
2022–2023Tracking Scandal Class ActionsApple tracked users via first-party apps despite privacy settings being turned off.More than a dozen class actions were filed after researchers found Apple’s apps sent detailed usage data back to Apple.Impact: Raised questions about Apple’s “Privacy. That’s iPhone.” marketing claims.
2022–2024Apple Data Privacy LitigationApple collected user data through its proprietary apps (App Store, Music, TV, etc.) even when users disabled tracking settings.Plaintiffs argued Apple violated privacy laws by ignoring “Share Analytics” and “Allow Apps to Request to Track” settings.Status: A federal judge allowed parts of the case to proceed, especially those tied to the “Share Analytics” setting.
2024Apple Employee Privacy Lawsuit (California PAGA)Apple allegedly monitored employees via personal devices and suppressed speech about compensation and working conditions.Claims included surveillance of geolocation and personal photos, violating labor and privacy laws.Status: Filed under California’s Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA).

Apple Summary

Data Sharing with Law Enforcement: Apple has complied with thousands of data requests from U.S. law enforcement, including handing over sensitive user data.

Inconsistent Privacy Protections: Studies have shown that Apple’s own apps (e.g., Siri, Safari, iMessage) collect data even when users believe they’ve disabled tracking.

Advanced Data Protection Limitations: While Apple introduced end-to-end encryption for iCloud, the feature is not enabled by default and excludes certain data types like Contacts and Calendars.

Google Privacy

Major privacy lawsuits, verdicts, and settlements involving Google (oldest first):

$ cat ./google-privacy-lawsuits.tsv — oldest first
Year(s)CaseAllegationDetailsOutcome / Status
2024Incognito Mode Lawsuit SettlementGoogle continued tracking users even when they used private browsing (Incognito mode).—Google agreed to destroy billions of data records collected from users who believed they were browsing privately.
2025$314 Million Android Data Privacy LawsuitGoogle collected data from idle Android devices without user permission and used it for advertising, consuming users’ cellular data.Filed in 2019 on behalf of 14 million Californians.A jury in San Jose, California, found Google liable and awarded $314 million.
2025$425 Million Privacy VerdictGoogle improperly tracked smartphone activity from 2016 to 2024, even when users had turned off tracking features, and used the data to sell targeted ads without user consent.The class action covered 98 million smartphones and alleged violations of California privacy laws.A federal jury in San Francisco ordered Google to pay $425.7 million. Google denied wrongdoing and plans to appeal, claiming users had control over their data.
2025$1.375 Billion Settlement with TexasGoogle violated Texas privacy laws, including collecting geolocation, incognito search data, and biometric information without proper consent.—Google agreed to pay $1.375 billion (about $1.4 billion) to settle.
2025€325 Million CNIL Fine (France)Deceptive privacy practices — manipulating cookie consent and inserting ads in Gmail without proper user approval.—France’s CNIL fined Google €325 million (~$381 million).
Combined Penalties: Together with the $425 million U.S. verdict above, Google faced about $806 million in privacy penalties in 2025.

Fines & Settlements at a Glance

$ cat ./privacy-penalties.tsv — money Apple & Google have been ordered or agreed to pay
YearCompanyCaseTypeAmount
2024GoogleIncognito Mode lawsuitSettlementNo cash — billions of data records destroyed
2025AppleSiri Privacy Lawsuit (Lopez v. Apple)Settlement$95 million
2025GoogleAndroid idle-data lawsuitJury verdict$314 million
2025GoogleSmartphone tracking class actionJury verdict (under appeal)$425.7 million
2025GoogleState of TexasSettlement$1.375 billion
2025GoogleFrance CNILRegulatory fine€325 million (~$381 million)
Total (CNIL fine converted to USD)≈ $2.59 billion

Timeline of Google Spying & Privacy Violations

2019

Google Home & Nest Devices: Human contractors were found to be reviewing audio clips from Google Home and Nest devices, including private conversations, without users’ knowledge. Devices were triggered accidentally by sounds resembling “Hey Google,” leading to unintended recordings.

Dutch Investigation: A report by VRT NWS revealed that Google subcontractors listened to sensitive conversations, including domestic disputes and private bedroom talks, recorded by Google Home devices.

2020–2023

Google Assistant Class Action Lawsuit: Filed in California, alleging that Google Assistant recorded conversations without consent, even when users didn’t activate it. A class was certified for users who bought Google-made devices.

Google’s Internal Database Leak: A leak revealed thousands of privacy violations, including recording children’s voices, saving license plates from Street View, and leaking home addresses and deleted YouTube history.

2024

Cloud Contact Center AI Lawsuit: Google’s AI-powered customer service tool allegedly eavesdropped on phone calls, recorded conversations, and used them to train AI models without informing users. Plaintiffs argue this violates California’s wiretapping laws.

Incognito Mode Settlement: See Incognito Mode Lawsuit Settlement above.

2025

A record year for penalties — see the entries above: $314M Android verdict, $425M tracking verdict, $1.375B Texas settlement, and €325M CNIL fine.

Google Summary

Historical Privacy Concerns: Since the mid-2000s, Google has been criticized for cooperating with intelligence agencies, tracking users via cookies and analytics, sharing data across platforms (e.g., Gmail, YouTube, Search), and dropping bans on personally identifiable info in ad services (DoubleClick, 2016). In 2007, Privacy International ranked Google as “Hostile to Privacy.”

Google’s devices and services have been found to record audio even when users didn’t intend to activate them. Human review of voice recordings was part of Google’s efforts to improve AI, but raised serious privacy concerns. Multiple lawsuits and settlements have resulted in billions of dollars in penalties. Users can review and delete their voice recordings via Google’s My Activity page.

Note: this page cross-references the security material on the Apple & Google Security page.
NORMAL mcbrides_resources.local
James McBride — Instructor █